If you’ve ever wondered who these people are that sell their things on Amazon and become rich in the process, I’m here with a reality check: it’s really, really hard to make money selling things in this competitive marketplace. While I started this little side hustle as a joke – and perhaps as a way to procrastinate – I learned a valuable lesson about assessing what is, and isn’t, worth my time.

Selling books on Amazon isn’t worth my time. Read on for my experiment, the lessons I learned, and how I tried to sell my international bookstore only to be rejected by an 8 year old.

The life-changing magic of tidying up – and selling –  my books.

Erica persuaded (dragged) me into her Marie Kondo tidying up exercise over the holidays. The slogan for the week was, “does it bring you joy?” My extensive book collection bore the brunt of her joy.

In all due respects, the collection was in need of a clean out. I had horrible airport reads, half a shelf of literary novels from the African American women’s literature class I took in college, and textbooks from chemical engineering and my MBA program that were weighing down the shelves.

I had 154 books in total that no longer brought me joy but more importantly, needed to go to make room for baby stuff.

We were packing them up to drop off at the numerous charity shops that line the high street (downtown in America speak) when I had a revelation.

Sell the books on Amazon.

I bet there were a few golden nuggets in the collection. My MBA textbooks were never opened. They gave them to us as part of our tuition but the professors didn’t use them. Yes, wasteful.  

A great way to diversify Gellerholz LLC from a blog while staying in our expertise of business strategy, side hustling, and entrepreneurship. The corporation must grow. The shareholders expect it. Our dog deserves a bigger backyard.

While selling books on Amazon isn’t really any of those things above, I thought it would be fun and a way to earn a few dollars from my book collection.

I quickly learned that selling books on Amazon must not be taken lightly. The marketplace is cut-throat and one must be on their A-game to make the sale.

It’s Too Easy to Open an Amazon Bookstore

It’s so easy to open an Amazon bookstore, it’s practically a trap for someone with a bad idea to instantly take action and implement said bad idea.

On Christmas day, I went to Amazon Seller Central. The site was self-explanatory for opening an account, naming our family-run bookstore, and entering our bank info for Amazon to send us our bags of money. Since we are living in the UK, I set up the account to sell mainly in the UK but by default, I can sell to most of the European Union.

Just like that, Gellerholz Books became an international bookstore.

I checked out a few blogs to get tips and tricks for setting it up. Heaven forbids I jump into this endeavor without at least 5 minutes of research. One experienced gentleman gave some good advice: he picked up a book at a flea market and knew it would be a big seller as it was an unusual sci-fi, self-help book. This genre is rare in bookstores so people look for these on Amazon. He bought it for $1 and sold it for $5.

This $4 success story should have been a red-flag for me.

Putting my extensive and exclusive book inventory in the marketplace was super easy. With Elf playing on the TV, I entered the International Standard Book Number (ISBN) (8 to 13 digits above the barcode) for each book into Amazon’s catalog. The cover picture, book details, and quantity being sold instantly popped up.

From the drop-down, I selected the condition of the book and determined if I wanted to be the lowest price or enter a higher price. Averaging 2 minutes per book, I quickly had most of my collection for sale to the European Union while “spreading Christmas Cheer, by singing loud for all to hear” with Buddy the Elf playing in the background.

Waiting for my Amazon Auto-Payment

On December 28th, came my first sale! The Millionaire Next Door: The Surprising Secrets of America’s Wealthy was purchased by a wonderful lady from Romford, London. Excellent choice.

I jumped into this enterprise based on my expected cost of goods sold (COGS) or cost of my books. In my mind, my COGS were $0. The lack of joy I felt for them made them worth nothing to me. Therefore, Gellerholz Books had a very low bar to put us in the black.

For each book, in the UK, Amazon gives the seller $3.75 for postage. Regardless of the size or weight of the book. Small, paperback books cost about $2.00 to ship while a large, hardcover textbook cost about $11.50 for postage. This varies based on size and weight but I’ll use averages going forward.

Besides postage, another cost is packaging and printing the packing slip. Low cost but the recommended padded envelope cost about $0.35 when bought in bulk or $0.80 when bought at the local stationery store. I’m not selling enough books to justify buying in bulk. Damage to the book during shipment will result in a return and/or a bad review. Two things I don’t want for Gellerholz Books – your neighborhood international bookstore. Therefore, I used the nice padded envelopes.

Amazon also charges a fee for every sale. The fee is a sliding scale starting with a default $1.00 per book. They also take a 15% referral fee for books. They tack on some other sliding rate fees to keep you guessing.

After a few sales, I realized my break-even point (the price I needed to sell it for in order to not lose money) wasn’t as low as I expected. Based on average postage, packing, and Amazon fees my breakeven sales price was $3.18 for a small, paperback. A hardcover textbook break-even price was $15.77. A lot of folks are selling books for a $1 or less. I can only assume they are losing money or getting a big discount on bulk postage, packaging, and lower Amazon fees by having a business account.

Amazon books break-even price

These expenses don’t include my own time. I’m not cheap. The initial set-up of the bookstore and entering the books into Amazon took a few hours. After that, I averaged about 15 minutes for packaging and shipping per book. How much was I earning per hour? Probably not enough.

Time to Not Hire an Account

In mid-January, I had a few sales under my belt. I was selling 3 to 4 books a week. Then one day at the post office I got in a tiny quarrel with the worker. I accused them of over-charging me postage. Afterward, I realized was getting too passionate about this store. So, I took some time to look back on my accounting notebooks.

Small, soft-copy books were selling the best but the money in the small books was tiny. It was obvious that the money is in textbooks.

As Erica poignantly asked, “are textbooks selling?”

No, no they are not. No one needs a textbook in January and February. The profit-making part of the business opens when school is back in session. 6 months from now.

Amazon books profit

Revenue, expenses, profit, and $/hour earned from Gellerholz Books for 2.2 months of hard work. March didn’t get better.

From the table above, you can see I was making on average $11/hr with this job in February and March. It was fun, but was it worth it?

Book Store Differentiation

Selling books is like selling a commodity – wheat, oranges, oil, etc. There is very little, to no differentiation between products. So how do Amazon sellers stand-out?

When a customer sees your product, they can only see your reviews and review rankings. A short time seller like me won’t have my storefront open long enough to get reviews. I’ve sold 14 books and still don’t have a review.

Not to mention, I’m competing against UK charity shops. That just made me feel lousy. I don’t want to compete against a charity shop. My books and time are better spent walking them down to a charity shop than walking to the post office a couple times a week.


Achieving our 2018 Goals

I’m not going to lie, it felt great to be selling. I like the operations aspect of checking my inbox, printing the package slip, shipping it to the customer, closing the deal, and getting the payment from Amazon.

It is a real business. Amazon Seller Central tracks all your metrics for their own benefit and mine. It is fun to see the health of the store via their dashboard. My record was flawless.

Too bad I wasn’t improving our living standard. I could buy a few pints at a pub, once a month, at this rate.

We have our 2018 goals. These goals are our life priority focus items. Anything else is just a distraction.

These results are really no surprise. If I would have taken the time upfront to estimate the cost of shipping, Amazon fees, and price of my books, I could have realized right away this venture would not have been worth it.

Gellerholz Bookstore closed its doors. Decision made. A few clearance sales in March but besides those, the books were packed up and carried to the charity shop.

Onto the next business idea for Gellerholz LLC.


My Exit Strategy

My textbooks are worth a pretty penny and their listing price is well above the break-even point above. I’m talking sale prices of $40 to a $100. Chemical Engineers and MBA students are chomping at the bit for this stuff.

While I love the charity shops, before giving them my extremely valuable textbooks, I looked for options to give someone this amazing opportunity to buy a family-run, international bookstore.

After speaking to my lawyers, business partner, and accountants, I identified a potential buyer: the 8-year old daughter of a co-worker. She’s brighter than most 8-year olds and I figured this would be a good opportunity for her to learn to start a business, run the numbers, and experience the thrill of the sale. 

My pitch deck was spectacular. I went through all the numbers, the opportunity, and the pot of gold come school season. I offered to let them come over that night to pick up the books. 

Because she is smarter than the average 8-year old, she turned me down. It was easy for her to see there was no money in this game and her time was better spent in school than walking books down to the post office to sell.

While Gellerholz Books was immediately disbanded when I donated the last box of books, I learned some valuable lessons from my first side hustle:

  • Anything that is that easy to start probably isn’t going to bring you a massive return
  • Run the numbers before you jump into anything. Was it worth it for me to make $11/hr when we have bigger goals that I could’ve been working on?
  • Have an end goal in mind. If an 8-year-old girl isn’t willing to take over your business, it probably wasn’t the best idea to begin with

This was my first side hustle, but it certainly won’t be my last. 


How we meal prep and cut our food budget by 30%

  Join the Project! Everything you need to be smarter with your money, delivered weekly.  You know those people who can effortlessly whip up dinner while simultaneously holding a conversation, corralling their kids, and setting a beautiful table? Jordan and I are not...

read more

Creating a Life That’s Worth It

  Join the Project! Everything you need to be smarter with your money, delivered weekly.  When I met my husband, Jordan, at the tail end of our senior year in college, he got my attention with an unusual pick-up line: “I promise that with me, you’ll have a lifetime of...

read more

The Secret to Spending Money Well

  Join the Project! Everything you need to be smarter with your money, delivered weekly.  Last week I had two very different experiences, both involving £3 and lattes. (Sorry in advance for using the over-used latte example. But I can’t rewrite my real life so just...

read more


A guide to help you embrace freedom, overcome overwhelm, and live a life that’s better than fine.

Money should be simple.

Join the Project!

Every Friday we bring you a roundup of the most interesting stories, things to learn, and ways to be smart with your money. Sent straight to your inbox.

You're almost in - just head over to your email to confirm and then you're on the list!

Money Makeover The Worth Project

Quickly get your finances in order.

It’s time to use money as a tool to live a better life. And not just when you’re 65. A better life now. Let’s spend the next 24 hours re-thinking your money. Grab my FREE guide and start your 5 simple steps today!

You're almost in. Head to your email to download the worksheet.

Join the Project!

Every Friday we bring you a roundup of the most interesting stories, things to learn, and ways to be smart with your money. Sent straight to your inbox.

You're almost in - just head over to your email to confirm and then you're on the list!

Pin It on Pinterest